I remember a feeling more than I remember any single presentation or session.
It was the feeling of sitting there at 10 of 10 and realizing that I did not have to think only within the boundaries of what child welfare had always allowed itself to be. I did not have to think only about how to make foster care a little better, or how to make the next policy a little less harmful, or how to improve the machinery we had inherited.
I could think about something else entirely.
That may sound simple, but for me it was liberating. The timing of 10 of 10 was important in ways I could not fully name at the time. I knew I was preparing to go into a federal leadership role, even if I could not yet talk about it publicly. I was thinking about priorities, about the national field, about what was possible and what was not. And then I found myself in a room where people were asking a much more basic question: What do children and families actually need to thrive?
Not what do systems need to keep operating.
Not what do we need to do to get better at what we have always done.
What do families need?
That question stayed with me. It still does.
There was also another moment I remember clearly, though not because I enjoyed it at first. We were sent out into Minneapolis and told to go talk to someone we did not know, to listen, to ask about their experience. I remember thinking immediately, “No, I cannot do that.” It was uncomfortable. I did not feel prepared for it.
But that, too, stayed with me.
Because not long after, in the federal role, I found myself needing to do exactly that again and again. Meet people I did not know. Ask what was on their minds. Listen to what they had lived. Hear what the system had done to them and failed to do for them. And not listen as a courtesy, or as a listening session to be checked off, but as a source of knowledge and accountability.
What shifted in me at 10 of 10 was the freedom to stop accepting the existing frame.
I did not walk into the Children’s Bureau thinking our task was to build a better foster care system. I walked in believing we had to put our attention where it belonged: on prevention, family support, and creating the conditions in which families never need to come into contact with the child welfare system in the first place.
That belief was strengthened by the people I met and listened to. Young people who had lived in foster care. Parents who had experienced the system’s power in their own lives. Kin, caregivers, advocates, community leaders, and people who were tired of systems speaking about them without them.
I do not want to overstate my own role in what changed, but I do believe we helped elevate those voices. We helped create a stronger expectation that people with lived expertise should not be invited in after decisions are made. They should help shape the work from the beginning.
That was not always easy inside government. There were moments when the direction we were taking did not sit well with everyone. I was once criticized for trying to run a social justice initiative out of the federal government. I have never thought that was much of a criticism. If there is any place where justice ought to matter, it is in the public systems that have the authority to separate children from their families.
The work could not be done from behind a desk. I wanted to be in the field. I wanted to hear what people were trying, what was working, and what families were telling us they needed. That carried risk, but it was also what made the role meaningful.
The last decade has been a process of staying with that question: How do we help families get what they need without making separation the price of admission?
At the Children’s Bureau, David Kelly and I worked with many others to advance a national conversation about prevention, family integrity, and child and family well-being. We tried to move the field away from the belief that foster care should be the central response to family hardship. We pushed for funding flexibility because funding determines behavior. If we mostly pay for foster care and adoption, we should not be surprised when we get more foster care and adoption. If we pay for family support, legal help, concrete assistance, and community-based prevention, we can begin to get something very different.
One concrete change I remain proud of was allowing federal funding for legal representation for parents. That was not simply a technical policy adjustment. It was about voice. Parents deserve to be heard in what happens to them and their children. They also deserve to help the field understand what is needed writ large.
We also pushed, repeatedly, for Title IV-E funds to be used more flexibly so that community-based organizations and local efforts could support families before separation became likely. We did not get everything through Congress that we hoped for. That is the truth. But I still believe the idea matters and that it continues to gain traction because it is fundamentally right.
The third thing I am most proud of is less a policy than a way of working. I built relationships with people who had lived experience in the system, and those relationships continue to shape me. There is still hardly a week that goes by when I am not talking, texting, or emailing with someone who spent time in foster care or experienced the system as a parent. It is not just hearing their stories. It is experiencing their wisdom.
That wisdom has to be built into the work. It is not optional. It is not an add-on. It is not a nice thing to do when time allows. Without it, I do not know how one can do this work with integrity.
I believe the conversation shifted.
Not completely. Not enough. But it shifted.
The field began to talk more seriously about prevention. We saw growth in community-based and community-driven approaches to supporting families. During our time at the Children’s Bureau, we invested federal resources in community collaborations, funding more than 20 localities to develop approaches rooted in their own communities. Some of those efforts have continued and sustained themselves beyond the initial federal investment.
We used every vehicle we could to lift up examples of family support, lived expertise, and community-led work. At the Children’s Bureau, that included using the Children’s Bureau Express, the Children’s Bureau’s periodic newsletter, to convey messages of family support and highlight successful efforts. After leaving government, David and I knew we needed another vehicle for that kind of influence and storytelling. That became part of the work of the Family Justice Group and the Family Justice Journal: creating space for local efforts, lived experience, advocacy, policy promotion, and voices that can help the field see differently.
The Family First Prevention Services Act deserves a complicated assessment. It helped diminish the role of congregate care, and it opened federal funding so children could remain with parents entering substance use treatment in certain circumstances. Those are important contributions. But I do not believe families should have to pick from a government-approved menu of services in order to receive help. A family may need housing, food, utilities, transportation, legal help, or something else entirely. The starting point should be talking with families and communities, not asking whether their need fits an evidence-based service category created somewhere far from their lives.
Families and communities should be in the driver’s seat. Government’s role should be to support them, not to narrow their options.
What is needed now is more fundamental than another program or pilot.
We have to make it possible for families to ask for help without fear.
That means we must take on mandatory reporting as we know it. Too many of the people a family might turn to for help are mandatory reporters. Too many parents have to work up the courage to say they are living in their car, or cannot buy food, or need help keeping the lights on, only to have that request become a hotline call. We should not have built a system in which asking for help can become the first step toward losing your children.
We need community alternatives so that people who might otherwise call a child abuse and neglect hotline can call someone who can actually help. We need to remove the penalties and fears that lead professionals to call hotlines because they do not know what else to do. We need pathways that allow families themselves to reach out and say, “We need help,” without fear that their children will be removed.
We also need to fund community-based groups directly. I do not believe those resources should have to flow through the very agency that holds the power to separate children from parents. Families will not fully trust the agency that can take their children away. If we want humane and compassionate support, we have to build it in places families can trust.
And we have to make asking for help a sign of strength, not a sign of failure.
That will require flexibility in funding. It will require shifting resources away from investigation and surveillance and toward community-based prevention and support. It will require an off-ramp for mandated reporters when what they are seeing is not abuse or neglect, but poverty, stress, isolation, or unmet need.
It will require us to be honest about the fact that the current structure cannot get us where we need to go.
When I think back to 10 of 10, I think about the freedom to think without the usual limits.
We may not be able to overcome every barrier at once. But we can refuse to let the old boundaries define the future.
The question is not whether we can build a better foster care system.
The question is whether we have the courage to build what families needed all along.
---
Jerry Milner, DSW, is Co-Director of the Family Justice Group and former Associate Commissioner of the U.S. Children’s Bureau. He began his career as a front-line social worker in Alabama and has devoted his career to transforming child welfare into approaches that strengthen families, prevent unnecessary separation, and invest in community-based support.
---